Hmm... no idea, I stopped reading sigs once I get to the part where they brag about what they have. Its so unbecoming...
Um, I guess my vote is for whoever's sig does not contain the words "rank", "astral", "sky" (not relating to the heavenly body), any craft followed by 60 or more, hard-to-snag items/spells like Fenrir and Optical Hats, a list of all the jobs they got past 50, a list of genkai's completed, a list of elemental staves procured, a list of AF and relic acquired, a list of... ***** it, lists in general, or ego-driven statements like {Impossible to gauge!}
I respect humble folks more than gloaters ^^;